Skint Dad

Where Every Penny Counts

  • Home
  • Save money
    • Save money on water bills
    • How to save money on groceries
    • Save money on energy bills
    • Frugal living tips
    • 1p Saving Challenge
  • Make money
    • Make money online
    • Best side hustle ideas
    • Best paid surveys
    • Genuine work from home jobs
  • Manage money
    • Best budgeting apps
    • Average household bills
    • Credit score apps
  • Help & Support
  • News
  • Deals
    • Kids Eat Free
    • Farmfoods offers
    • Heron Foods offers
    • Blue Light Card discounts list
    • When is the Next sale
  • About us
    • Contact us
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / News / CMA investigates Bannatyne, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel over extra charges

Skint Dad is reader supported. Some links may earn us a small commission. Learn more

CMA investigates Bannatyne, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel over extra charges

by Ricky Willis · published 21 November 2026 at 15:10 · updated 21 November 2026 at 15:10

The CMA is investigating pricing at Bannatyne, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel. Find out what extra charges to check and what your rights are.

Person holding a bank card while using a laptop to make an online payment
Photo: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels

Three well-known holiday and gym businesses are being investigated over concerns that customers may not have been shown the full price before booking or signing up.

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) announced investigations into Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel on 18 November 2026.

The watchdog is looking at whether compulsory charges were added later in the booking process rather than being included in the price customers first saw.

No wrongdoing has been established, and the CMA has made no findings against any of the three businesses.

What is the CMA investigating?

According to the CMA’s announcement, each investigation is looking at different charges.

  • Bannatyne Health Club: Whether joining fees and charges for using certain facilities were added later instead of being shown upfront.
  • Secret Escapes: Whether holiday prices included compulsory resort fees, local taxes and ATOL fees, and whether the prices of flights and other parts of a holiday were accurately shown from the start.
  • Caledonian Travel: Whether advertised holiday prices included compulsory charges such as single-person supplements and city taxes.

A Bannatyne Group spokesman told the PA news agency that the business was fully assisting with the investigation and providing the information required.

We haven’t been able to verify public responses from Secret Escapes or Caledonian Travel.

What does the law say about extra charges?

Since April 2025, businesses have been required to include compulsory charges in the total price shown to customers upfront.

The rules are designed to stop something called ‘drip pricing’.

That’s when something looks cheaper at first, but unavoidable charges appear as you go through the buying process.

For example, you might see a gym membership advertised at £30 a month, only to discover a compulsory joining fee.

The Skint List

Make your money go further

Money news, useful deals and practical ways to save or earn a bit extra.

From Ricky at Skint Dad, every Sunday morning. Free.

By joining, you agree to receive The Skint List by email. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy.

Or you could find a holiday at a good price, then discover additional taxes and charges before paying.

Businesses can still charge for optional extras, such as room upgrades. But charges you cannot avoid must normally be included in the price from the beginning.

If the exact amount genuinely can’t be calculated upfront, businesses must clearly explain how it will be worked out.

The CMA recently raised similar concerns about hidden delivery charges when shopping online.

What should you check before booking a holiday?

Don’t rely on the first price you see.

Before paying, check the total cost for everyone travelling, including any compulsory booking fees, local taxes, resort charges and single-person supplements.

Some charges might be collected when you arrive. That doesn’t necessarily mean they can be left out of the advertised price.

Also check what’s included, such as flights, baggage and transfers, and what costs extra.

If you’re comparing several holidays, look at what each one will actually cost your family rather than whichever has the lowest starting price.

What about joining a gym?

Before signing up, check whether there’s a joining fee, which facilities are included and how long the contract lasts.

Some memberships let you leave each month, while others tie you in for a year or longer.

Also check the cancellation rules and how much notice you’ll need to give.

If you already have a membership, it’s worth checking your regular payments too. Our guide to forgotten subscriptions explains how to spot payments you might no longer need.

Skint Dad says:

The cheapest monthly membership isn’t always the cheapest overall.

Take two made-up examples.

One gym charges £30 a month, plus a £60 joining fee. Over 12 months, that’s £420.

Another charges £32 a month with no joining fee. Over the same period, that’s £384.

You’d save £36 by choosing the gym with the higher monthly price.

It’s a simple calculation, but one worth doing before committing your money.

What if you’ve already paid an unexpected charge?

You may have rights, depending on what you booked and how the charge was presented.

For qualifying package holidays, the Package Travel Regulations 2018 provide an important protection.

If certain additional fees weren’t properly disclosed before you agreed to the booking, you aren’t required to pay those undisclosed charges.

However, this doesn’t mean every unexpected charge is automatically refundable.

For gyms, if you joined online or over the phone, you’ll usually have a 14-day cooling-off period. You may have to pay for services you’ve already used if you asked for your membership to start immediately.

If you signed up at the gym itself, you don’t normally have an automatic right to cancel within 14 days.

What to do if a charge wasn’t made clear

If you’ve paid more than expected, here’s where to start:

  1. Check your paperwork. Look at your booking confirmation, emails and any screenshots showing the original price.
  2. Contact the business in writing. Explain which charge wasn’t made clear and ask for an explanation or refund.
  3. Make a formal complaint if necessary. If the business refuses, ask it to explain its decision in writing.
  4. Get independent advice. Citizens Advice can help you work out your options, including whether you might be able to challenge a payment through your bank.

You can contact the Citizens Advice consumer service on 0808 223 1133 in England and Wales.

It can also pass concerns about unclear prices to Trading Standards.

Could customers get refunds?

Possibly, but nothing has been decided.

If the CMA finds that consumer law has been broken, it can fine businesses up to 10% of their worldwide turnover and order compensation for affected customers.

However, being a customer of Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes or Caledonian Travel doesn’t automatically mean you’re entitled to money back.

The investigations are still at an early stage, with the CMA expecting to provide its next case updates in April 2027.

If you’ve already paid a charge that wasn’t made clear, you don’t need to wait for those investigations to finish before raising it with the business.

And if you’re about to book a holiday or join a gym, check the full cost before committing your money.

Ricky Willis

About Ricky Willis

Ricky Willis is the founder of Skint Dad. Drawing on his own experiences, he shares practical ways to save money, cut household costs and earn extra cash to help families make their money go further.

Ricky and Naomi Willis

Ricky and Naomi Willis, founders and editors of the Skint Dad website.

We know how heavy money pressure can feel, so we share simple, practical help to make everyday money feel more manageable.

Read more about us.

Buy Skint Dad's book Make Every Penny Count
Skint Dad in the media

Explore

Save money

Make money

Manage money

Buy our book

Budget recipes

Join the community

Buy Skint Dad a coffee

Information

About us

Contact us

Awards, Media and Press

Affiliate Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Cookie Policy

Terms & Conditions

Sitemap

Skint Dad

Business office:
K2 Tower
Bond Street
Hull
HU1 3EN

Skint Media Limited
Registered in England and Wales
Company number: 09991508

Registered office:
1st Floor 8b Lonsdale Gardens
Tunbridge Wells
Kent
TN1 1NU

Copyright © 2026 · Skint Media Limited · All rights reserved · Registered in England and Wales with company number 09991508

Skint Dad
Menu
  • Home
  • Save money
    • Save money on water bills
    • How to save money on groceries
    • Save money on energy bills
    • Frugal living tips
    • 1p Saving Challenge
  • Make money
    • Make money online
    • Best side hustle ideas
    • Best paid surveys
    • Genuine work from home jobs
  • Manage money
    • Best budgeting apps
    • Average household bills
    • Credit score apps
  • Help & Support
  • News
  • Deals
    • Kids Eat Free
    • Farmfoods offers
    • Heron Foods offers
    • Blue Light Card discounts list
    • When is the Next sale
  • About us
    • Contact us
  • Subscribe