Skint Dad

Where Every Penny Counts

  • Home
  • Save money
    • Save money on water bills
    • How to save money on groceries
    • Save money on energy bills
    • Frugal living tips
    • 1p Saving Challenge
  • Make money
    • Make money online
    • Best side hustle ideas
    • Best paid surveys
    • Genuine work from home jobs
  • Manage money
    • Best budgeting apps
    • Average household bills
    • Credit score apps
  • Help & Support
  • News
  • Deals
    • Kids Eat Free
    • Farmfoods offers
    • Heron Foods offers
    • Blue Light Card discounts list
    • When is the Next sale
  • About us
    • Contact us
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Save Money / Supermarket “Deals” Are Still Misleading Customers

Skint Dad is reader supported. Some links may earn us a small commission. Learn more

Supermarket “Deals” Are Still Misleading Customers

by Naomi Willis · updated 28 August 2019

Some supermarket “deals” and “special offers” are still misleading customers, and we’re not saving as much money as we think.

shopping trolley at the supermarket

We all know to keep an extra eye open, so we don’t get burned when supermarket shopping.

Get a sign-up bonus with Swagbucks

Earn a bit of extra money in your spare time with surveys, offers and other simple tasks you can do at home.

New users can currently get a bonus when they sign up.

Claim sign-up bonus

I know many people who shop in three or four supermarkets, so they can get the best overall price for items they buy week in week out.

However, that’s not possible for all of us and should we have to be going this far to save money?

Supermarket “special offers” and “deals” have always known to be a bit sketchy, as you can no doubt find a different pack size and end up paying less.

The government even stepped in and gave pricing guidelines to stop us from getting caught out but, according to research from Which?, these discounts are still misleading.

Supermarket offers

Smiling woman shopping at the supermarket and holding a discount sign

Knowing that the supermarkets play a pricing game, we are already keen to look out for when offers are on.

For instance, Pringles – my eldest loves these things!

Every time we’ve in a shop, I get the infamous, “mum, mum, muuuum … please can I…?!”

But, she cannot have them until they’re on offer, and that will be regularly. I won’t pay the full price but will wait until they drop to £1.20-odd (or even head to Poundstretcher, where they are usually around the same price all the time if they have them in).

The Skint List

Make your money go further

Money news, useful deals and practical ways to save or earn a bit extra.

From Ricky at Skint Dad, every Sunday morning. Free.

By joining, you agree to receive The Skint List by email. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy.

She is starting to catch on that we only get them on offer (and that the price reductions are very regular).

Don’t lose out

It can be tempting to grab an offer because it’s on the shelf in front of you – however, it may be best to leave it there.

Here are a few ways you can save money when looking for a supermarket deal:

  • Keep a list of the prices you usually pay (maybe in the notes on your phone). You can use this to track if an offer is higher or lower than you want to stretch to.
  • Many of the deals are on branded goods. Look to brand down, and you’ll make an immediate and ongoing saving.
  • See if you can double up on offers. Use cashback apps like CheckoutSmart to make even more savings on your food shop.
  • Use the tool on MySupermarket to track the price changes over time. You can add a price alert, so you know when the price adjusts.
  • Shop around and don’t feel you need to be loyal to one store – just because you get reward points for shopping there, it doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll save money overall.
  • Look for tell-tell signs on the price label. This Tesco tip from Skint Chef allows you to see when an offer is due to end.

Misleading supermarket offers

The consumer champion, Which?, has looked at supermarket pricing from May 20018 to June 2019 and analysed 459 branded and supermarket own-brand products.

They looked at pricing using MySupermarket at seven of the big supermarkets to see what kind of deals we’ve been getting, which includes Asda, Iceland, Morrisons, Ocado, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and Waitrose.

Sadly, they saw that multibuys actually cost you more despite the alleged offer!

Discounts on pricing showing you a before prices were showing as wrong and special offer prices had been set at a low price for the majority of the year – not really so special then!

Here are some of the “deals” they found:

  • Cathedral City Mature Cheddar Cheese (350g)

You could buy the cheese at Morrisons on sale at “was £3.50 now £2” during the week of 17th September 2018. But, it was available for £2 the month before.

  • Kellogg’s Crunchy Nut

Iceland gave you a “2 for £4” offer – meaning it’s £2 a box. Looks good, until you realise you would have paid just £1.49 each of you bought them individually the week before.

  • Wall’s Carte D’Or Strawberry Ice Cream (1L)

Asda sold the ice cream on offer “was £3.50 now £2”. But, you could get it for £2 for the majority of the year already (and the “special offer” was on show for 12 weeks).

What did the supermarkets say?

An empty cart between shelves in the supermarket.

Natalie Hitchins, Which? Head of Home Products and Services, said:

“Four years on from our super-complaint on misleading pricing practices, many of the big supermarkets are clearly still in the wrong, with numerous examples of dodgy discounts and never-ending offers.

“These retailers must stop tricking shoppers with deceptive deals and spurious special offers – if not, the CMA must intervene to ensure that pricing guidelines are followed.”

Which? reached out to the supermarkets to get their views on their pricing.

Iceland said that it would review its promotional calendar and add the finding made by Which? – that’s really positive. Here’s some of the Iceland offers running at the moment.

Asda did not agree that their offers were misleading. Here are Asda’s latest offers.

Other supermarkets did not come back with a comment.

 

What do you think?

Are the “deals” you find not really deals?

Come and share your findings and real deals with other bargain hunters in the Reduce Your Supermarket Spend community.

Naomi Willis

About Naomi Willis

Naomi Willis is the co-founder of Skint Dad. Having overcome debt herself, she shares practical ways to save money on food, cut household costs and make family budgets stretch further.

Ricky and Naomi Willis

Ricky and Naomi Willis, founders and editors of the Skint Dad website.

We know how heavy money pressure can feel, so we share simple, practical help to make everyday money feel more manageable.

Read more about us.

Buy Skint Dad's book Make Every Penny Count
Skint Dad in the media

Explore

Save money

Make money

Manage money

Buy our book

Budget recipes

Join the community

Buy Skint Dad a coffee

Information

About us

Contact us

Awards, Media and Press

Affiliate Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Cookie Policy

Terms & Conditions

Sitemap

Skint Dad

Business office:
K2 Tower
Bond Street
Hull
HU1 3EN

Skint Media Limited
Registered in England and Wales
Company number: 09991508

Registered office:
1st Floor 8b Lonsdale Gardens
Tunbridge Wells
Kent
TN1 1NU

Copyright © 2026 · Skint Media Limited · All rights reserved · Registered in England and Wales with company number 09991508

Skint Dad
Menu
  • Home
  • Save money
    • Save money on water bills
    • How to save money on groceries
    • Save money on energy bills
    • Frugal living tips
    • 1p Saving Challenge
  • Make money
    • Make money online
    • Best side hustle ideas
    • Best paid surveys
    • Genuine work from home jobs
  • Manage money
    • Best budgeting apps
    • Average household bills
    • Credit score apps
  • Help & Support
  • News
  • Deals
    • Kids Eat Free
    • Farmfoods offers
    • Heron Foods offers
    • Blue Light Card discounts list
    • When is the Next sale
  • About us
    • Contact us
  • Subscribe